Cancellation of £90m Calverley Project Predicted “Within Two Months”

The controversial plan by Tunbridge Wells Borough Council to take on large debts to build new council offices and a theatre stands a strong chance of being cancelled soon, despite last week’s inconclusive special council meeting.

The fate of the £90million project is now in the hands of a group of ten Conservative councillors who don’t want the scheme, including Sean Holden who told Southborough News after Monday’s votes that it was “understood” by the other 18 Conservatives on the Borough Council that the scheme “wouldn’t happen”.

The planned project (that also includes a new car park as well as the council offices and a theatre big enough to attract West End shows) would require the removal of at least 70 trees and a section of parkland on the existing Calverley Grounds (pictured below).

Calv Car Park.jpg

Cllr Holden went along with the decision to pause – rather than cancel – the scheme at last Monday’s meeting. He said: “Being frank, some members of the Conservative Party  are committed to this: I think they need to be given time to come around to understanding that it can’t go on.”

Cllr Holden (pictured below) continued: “I hear what the people say and I’ve always known what the people think about this (project). I’ve never supported it. And now we have seen what they say and we have to take notice.”

Cllr Sean Holden.jpg

Cllr Holden welcomed the fact that talks with other parties on the council were planned and said: “What should come out of those talks is a cancellation of this operation. I have never voted for this project…and there are enough members of the Conservative group who take that view that it cannot go through.”

The special Council meeting was called after a slump in support for the Conservatives in the May Tunbridge Wells local election that went well beyond losses elsewhere in Kent.

Opponents feel the council would have to cut services to fund interest payments on the Calverley scheme’s debts and don’t want the historic park (below) diminished in size.

Calv Portrait.jpg

Cllr Holden concluded the cancellation: “has to be done within the next two months because of contracts and so on. We want it to be quite quick. I certainly don’t want this to be a prevarication. I don’t want them to come back with a reworked revamped idea of it. I want to stop it and then look at what we might do in this town of Tunbridge Wells.”

The new Borough Council has 28 Conservatives and 20 opposition councillors. In the opposition are Lib Dems 9, Alliance 6, Labour 4 and Independent 1.

Meanwhile Cllr David Scott (pictured below), who is the Conservative in charge of the development in the Borough, told Southborough News that investors were now coming to Tunbridge Wells because “developers expect us to move the town forward.”

Cllr David Scott

Cllr Scott warned: “We have managed to persuade developers to come into the town. We are at risk of ending up with developers saying we have stopped the reason for them coming into Tunbridge Wells.”

Cllr Scott said all of the alternatives to the £90m project “cost money and will impact the town. There is no future for this town if we ignore this. I am more than happy to consider any alternative. The Assembly Hall is not viable for very much longer.”

Cllr Scott continued: “If we were to actually postpone this by a year it would cost an awful lot more money to do that. If the view of the council is that we need to spend an awful lot more money to postpone it for a year, then that will be the view of the council. The council may come up with a different view.”

Asked if the green spaces of the Calverley Grounds (shown below) were now safe Cllr Scott said: “I’m not going to come to any conclusion at this point. I want to see us move forward and make a cost effective decision. I would like to see it done fairly rapidly ..within months.”

Calv Tree+sign.jpg

The noticeboard in the picture (above) includes this notice shown (below) that states that all the trees and shrubs behind the noticeboard would be lost.

Calv Tree sign.jpg

Calv Map.jpg

Calv Meadow.jpg

Cllr Scott made it clear he believes the current internal structure of the Town Hall was in such a poor state that it was “no longer fit for purpose” and needed to be rebuilt almost entirely behind the facade. He thought the protected council chamber could find an alternative use – perhaps a pub, using the example of the Opera House Weatherspoons.

Cllr Scott thought it might be feasible to attract a university to move in and pay to rebuild the Town Hall as a centre for learning.

However, a Southborough resident who listened into the meeting in an overspill room in the Town Hall rejected the idea that the existing building could no longer be used.

He supplied Southborough News with photos of the ornate plaster ceilings (below) that he said provided evidence the Tunbridge Wells Town Hall was a usable historic building and there was a strong case for council workers to stay in it, refurbishing where needed and sub-letting any rooms no longer needed.

Ceilings 1

Ceilings 2

The Southborough resident, Clive Davis, said: “These ceilings are beautiful and should be preserved for future generations. So many people do not realise what’s there until it’s gone.  The whole place should be listed.  It will never be replaced.  In fact I doubt the craftsmen are capable now of replacing it.”

The Alliance political group on the council,which was formed to stop the £90million Council borrowing, said it expects a new expert report called RIBA stage 4 will be published in July and show costs already exceeding the £90million budget.

The alliance’s Cllr David Hayward told Southborough News this would be the excuse the Conservative leadership would use to cancel the project. Cllr Hayward, who represents Pembury, is pictured below at last Monday’s meeting on the far right of the picture.

Calv Couuncil cu.jpg

Cllr Hayward said: “I am convinced that at the first opportunity they can to get out of it saving some face, they will.”

Cllr Hayward (below) argued that it would cost a lot less to refurbish the existing Assembly Hall theatre and Town Hall than the figure of £50million suggested by the Council leaders. He thought the Assembly Hall could be enlarged in a cost effective way with some extra space from the now empty police station next door, which the Council has already bid to purchase.

Cllr Hayward v2

Cllr Hayward said he wants a wider public consultation across the Borough on what to spend council money on to begin soon.

Listen to Conservative Cllr Sean Holden who has always opposed Calverley project and who now predicts its cancellation within two months:

Listen to the Conservative’s Cllr David Scott who is responsible for development in the town and doesn’t want the Calverley Project cancelled until an alternative is agreed:

In the council vote last Monday, 11 Conservatives voted against their own Conservative Council leader on Motion 3 which was proposed by the opposition and suggested major decisions on the project be referred to the full council, not just be decided by the Conservative run Council cabinet. The opposition motion carried by 30 votes from a mix of parties to 14 Conservatives.

The 11 Conservatives who rejected their leader’s advice and supported Motion 3 were:
Sean Holden (Benenden & Cranbrook),
Andy Fairweather (Frittenden & Sissinghurst),
Dr Linda Hall (Goudhurst & Lamberhurst),
Beverley Palmer (Hawkhurst & Sandhurst),
Patrick Thomson (Hawkhurst & Sandhurst),
Frank Williams (Sherwood),
Joe Simmons (Southborough North),
Julia Soyke (Speldhurst & Bidborough),
Julian Stanyer (Speldhurst & Bidborough)
Joy Podbury (Rusthall & Deputy Mayor),
James Scholes (Pantiles & Mayor of Borough)

The following 3 Conservatives did not attend the meeting:
Paul Barrington-King (Pembury),
Dr Ronen Basu (Culverden),
David Reilly (Pembury)

44 attended the meeting in Total. 19 of the opposition were there. Nick Pope of the Alliance was also there before the meeting began, but was forced to withdraw as his wife owns a flat overlooking Hoopers car park (that doesn’t overlook the park at all) but is affected by the Compulsory Purchase Order so could qualify for financial compensation for noise and dust disruption. Nick Pope was therefore told by council officials that he couldn’t vote on the issue he was elected on.

Conservatives Agree to Pause Calverley Square Theatre Plan

At a packed special meeting of the  Borough Council on Monday night it was agreed to stop all new spending on the planned Tunbridge Wells council offices and theatre.

There has been widespread public concern that the new civic centre would have led to the council into a heavy burden of debt.

Estimated borrowing would top £90million and the main Conservative backers of the plan lost their council seats at the recent local election.

Now the new Conservative leadership on the Borough Council has reflected on the election result and agreed a pause for consultation in the coming months.

Calv Couuncil.jpgA motion amended by the Conservative leadership at Monday’s meeting (shown above)  was approved by 24 votes to 20 which stated: “Cabinet be requested to stop all new expenditure on the Calverley Square project with immediate effect and to not enter into further commitments other than, with the involvement of all political parties and other relevant stakeholder groups, to manage an orderly consideration of all alternative proposals.”

The motion was supported by Southborough’s Conservative councillor Joe Simmons but opposed by Southborough’s 3 Labour members and one Lib Dem councillor who wanted a clearer halt to the scheme.

Leading Conservative Councillor Scott said he wanted a reevaluation of  all possible schemes but he argued the council did not have the “luxury” of not doing anything as he said £50 million needed to be spent on upgrading the existing theatre and council offices.

Councillor Scott said it was everybody’s job to come up with an answer and all of the options would cost money.

A further motion requesting the full council is consulted before any further key decisions are taken was passed by 30 votes to 14, even though it was opposed by the Conservative leader of the council.

This second vote saw around 10 Conservatives oppose their own leader, suggesting council policy remains in flux.

 

 

 

Diana Blackwell Elected to Lead Southborough Society with Renewed Focus on Younger Members

The Southborough Society has chosen Diana Blackwell as its new Chair, after she impressed members with her recent work on modernising the Society’s website and social media offerings.

The Society held its Annual General Meeting last Thursday (23rd May), which ended with the election of Diana Blackwell (pictured below), who has spent the last two years as the Society’s Planning Officer.

Diana Blackwell

Diana Blackwell explained to members that the new instagram account she created has already attracted over 300 followers in less than six months. She has also designed promotional material and created a new website to engage with a younger residents, which complements the Society’s Facebook and Twitter pages.

Diana Blackwell told the meeting her background was in art and education and she has taught photography at a local secondary school for the last ten years. She has also stepped in to the role of the Society’s School Liaison Officer.

She continued: “As Chair, I can offer an abundance of enthusiasm for progressing the Society. I think it is important that the Society also appeals to younger members to ensure the Society remains vibrant and engaged with different generations.”

Coat 1.jpg

The new website has a blog that currently features Southborough’s coat of arms including this image (above) from the hand painted sign that used to sit above the old Council office entrance.

Diana Blackwell set out her priorities: “Moving forward, I’d like the Society to become more active; campaigning for a greener town, preserving our town’s heritage and engaging more effectively with local schools; building on the foundations that the hard working committee have already laid.”

Diana Blackwell concluded: “I believe the Society has achieved a great deal in its almost fifty years, but I think now is the time to re-evaluate how we see the Society going forwards and what we can do to ensure the Society continues to grow, be outward looking and relevant for the future.”

Crop Decimus

The meeting had begun with a engaging talk about Decimus Burton called “The Listening Architect” by Paul Avis, of the Tunbridge Wells Civic Society, which detailed Decimus Burton’s work in Tunbridge Wells, Southborough and elsewhere.

Paul Avis stated that it could be argued that Decimus Burton’s success “lay in his humble approach to design – it is an approach that we are the richer for today….Some refused to compromise their approach to design, despite their clients’ needs and wishes. Decimus Burton, however, was somewhat unique in embracing different styles of architecture.”

Burton+image

The AGM heard that Southborough Society membership was static with 12 members departing and 11 joining, so the total membership stands at 318 members from 218 households, compared with 319 members from 217 households a year ago.

The Society also elected a new Treasurer.  Ian Kinghorn, who had been acting Chairman of the Society in recent months will remain on the Committee.  The Society is also strengthened with the return to the Committee of the experienced former Southborough Society Chair, Michael Howes.

The society’s new website is at:
https://southboroughsociety.org.uk/

The instagram account is:
https://www.instagram.com/southboroughsociety/

The twitter account is:

The Facebook Account is:
https://www.facebook.com/southboroughsociety/

 

 

Labour’s Alain Lewis is New Mayor of Southborough

Southborough Town Council met last week for the first time following May’s local elections and installed Cllr Alain Lewis from the Labour Party as the Town’s new Mayor and Chair of the Council.

Labour is now the largest single party on the Town Council, following the slump in support for the Conservatives as reported in the Southborough News article of May 3rd.

There are now 9 Labour, 6 Conservative and 3 Liberal Democrat members of the Town Council, which looks after local parks, Southborough Common and the cemetery. Planning and refuse are run by Tunbridge Wells Borough Council. Schools and Roads are in the control of Kent County Council.

Cllr Lewis (pictured below) was previously Deputy Mayor 4 years ago.

Alain Lewis new

Cllr Lewis told the “mayor making” Council meeting on 21st May that democracy was thriving in Southborough. He said: “At the recent elections voters clearly signalled that they want a change in the in the way our Council is run and operates.”

Cllr Lewis continued: “My view is that we must respect what residents are telling us. We are the servants of the people we represent, not expect them to be servants of their town council.”

And the new Mayor called on the Conservative run Borough and County Councils, who  therefore have 2 of the 3 votes in the Southborough Hub Project Board, to cooperate with the Town Council. Cllr Lewis said: “They need to support this council and enable us to carry out our mandate, rather than blocking our ideas at the Hub Project Board”.

The current proposed ground floor layout of the Southborough Hub is shown below:

New ground floor Feb19 v2Cllr Lewis concluded: “We must regain the trust of people who live in the town. We must be more transparent in the way we do business. We must listen more. We must do more to involve people in decision making. We must communicate better.”

Cllr Lewis asked that councillors work together on the following five big issues:

(1) We need to make sure that our finances are straight. We want the business plan for the Hub, details of land sales, and an informed forecast the impact of these on our local council taxes over the next few years.

(2) We need to make sure the Hub is fit for purpose. Despite the background of dispute about our new civic buildings we need to look forward and ensure they will meet the needs of the people who will be using them.

(3) We need to do more encourage involvement and contribution. Businesses, voluntary organisations, faith groups and individuals have a lot to offer to preserve and improve our town. Let’s make use of them.

(4) We need to address people’s concerns about roads and transport. Many of these are difficult issues but we could make some further progress on road safety and better transport links.

(5) We need to make our town greener! Climate change will be biggest issue for us all in the decades to come. Let’s do all we can to make our green contribution. Let’s plant trees, grow wild flowers, campaign against litter and do our bit to reducing the use of plastic.

Cllr Dianne Hill (pictured below) was elected as Deputy Mayor. She emphasised that the council covered High Brooms which has always been a distinctive community with its own proud history linked to the old brick and gas works.

Di wins

Cllr Hill said: “It is a community that doesn’t have public transport links to Southborough and as a consequence can sometimes feel apart from what is going on in our town and our town centre.”

Cllr Hill concluded: “We need to move on from the divisions we have seen develop over the last few years. Working together we can begin to enjoy again our work on this council and do things that encourage a sense of pride and achievement in our community.”

Cllr Hill emphasised the environmental issues: “We sit in an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty in the High Weald but at the same time we are choked by pollution and blighted by gridlocked traffic. As a town council we can play our own small part in starting to address some of these problems and I would like to see us setting ourselves a goal of becoming a green town.”

Meanwhile, David Elliot is the new leader of the Conservative Group on the Council and Ian Kinghorn is his Deputy. Mr Elliot told Southborough News he did not give a speech as he felt it was not appropriate. All of the Conservative Group voted to approve the election of Cllr Alain Lewis as Town Mayor.

Cllr Elliot said: “It will be interesting being part of the Opposition minority for a change. I can’t always be on the winning side!”

Trevor Poile is Back on Borough Council for Southborough After 12 Years Away

Liberal Democrat Trevor Poile has returned to the Tunbridge Wells Borough Council by defeating his Conservative opponent, Cllr David Elliott, in Southborough North.

Cllr Poile (pictured below) previously represented the same ward for 12 years between 1994 and 2007.  He told Southborough News: “This win is particularly special as I have come back as a Borough councillor for my home ward after 12 years.”

trevor-use

In the past decade, Cllr Poile has remained an active member of the Southborough Town Council.

He said: “I was not expecting to get over 50% of the votes, I’ll be honest. Clearly it was part of a trend across the Borough, but my win was much bigger than expected.”

SOUTHBOROUGH NORTH Votes Share of Vote
Trevor Poile Lib Dem 691 53% Elected
David Elliott Cons 414 31% Not elected
Nicholas Blackwell Labour 135 10% Not elected
Stephen Lukacs UKIP 76 6% Not elected

Cllr Poile continued: “It is a fantastic result for me but it is also quite humbling that I have had that support. It is always hard work to win an election but the hard work really starts when you become elected.”

Meanwhile, his defeated opponent Conservative David Elliott, who had represented the Southborough North seat on TWBC for the past 12 years, told Southborough News he was disappointed with the result.

Cllr Elliott, who remains on the Southborough Town Council, said: “We felt that Southborough North was a fairly safe seat. In the 2015 election, I took 58% of the vote and as Conservatives we have tended to concentrate our efforts elsewhere and perhaps neglected the North Ward.”

David Elliott told Southborough News that he “would be back” and was proud of his achievements as a Borough Councillor. Cllr Elliott (pictured below) took early retirement aged 56 in the year before his election. He said: “Since my election in May 2007, I have been working full time supporting local residents in the North Ward.”

Elliott new2

Cllr Elliott was briefly mayor of both Tunbridge Wells Borough and Southborough Town, when his one year as mayor in Tunbridge Wells and two years as mayor of Southborough overlapped for 15 hours. He pointed to his success on the Town Council improving Southborough Common – working with the Kent High Weald Partnership – and said: “My main achievement is that I have contributed towards delivering the Southborough Hub.”

Cllr Elliott says he will continue to work for Southborough as membership secretary of the Southborough and High Brooms District Overseas Friendship Association and he is also looking forward to organising the Classic Car show for the Lions Gala Day at Meadow’s School on 23rd June.

Cllr Poile reflected on the dramatic day of council defeats for the Conservatives: “The feel at the count at the Town Hall reminded me of the time in 1990s, when the Lib Dems took control of the Borough Council.”

He continued: “It was a perfect storm for the Conservatives. They have clearly been punished for what they’ve been proposing in the centre of Tunbridge Wells.”  Full details of Thursday’s Borough and Town Council results are written up in two more blogs I have already published.

Meanwhile, Labour won the Southborough and High Brooms ward on the Borough Council.  The victor was Luke Everitt (below) who said he was “over the moon.”

Luke Everitt

Cllr Everitt told Southbrough News that he thought the planned theatre and council office complex in Calverley Grounds was not viable, as it would never have generated the ticketing revenue it needed.  Having spent recent weeks on the streets canvassing for votes, he said “I have yet to meet anyone in support of the Civic Centre scheme.”

Cllr Everitt, who is 32 and who formerly worked in the Council election team, said he thought the Tunbridge Wells council chamber had become an “echo chamber” without serious scrutiny of policies, but that there was now a clear mandate from voters for change.

SOUTHBOROUGH & HIGH BROOMS Votes Share of Vote
Luke Everitt Labour 845 50% Elected
Alexis Bird Lib Dem 352 21% Not elected
Mark Puller Cons 309 18% Not elected
Christine Marshall UKIP 195 11% Not elected

Supporters of the Civic Centre project had pointed to the success of the Marlowe theatre in Canterbury (below) .  But Cllr Everitt pointed out the Marlowe had benefited from significant public investment in the past but had now left council control and become a trust, so – he said – “being lost to the public realm.”

Marlowe theatre

In the local votes a year ago, Conservative Joe Simmons (who voted against his own party’s Civic Centre plans) held onto his Borough Council seat for the Conservatives  with 51% of the vote in Southborough North. Meanwhile in the Southborough and High Brooms ward, Labour’s Alain Lewis was victorious with 62% of the vote.

Southborough has 2 Borough Councillors in North Ward and 3 in Southborough and High Brooms Ward, with Dianne Hill from Labour being the 3rd representing High Brooms.

Some of Labour’s Borough councillors are shown below celebrating Thursday’s results: Luke Everitt, Hugo Pound (in Sherwood), Dianne Hill and Alain Lewis.

Lab crop

Calverley Grounds £90 million Civic Project “Unlikely to Happen” After Slump in Conservative Vote

The plan by Tunbridge Wells Borough Council to borrow £90million to build new council offices and theatre in the town is on the brink of collapse after a devastating set of local election results for the ruling Conservative Group.

The leader of the Borough Council, David Jukes, lost his seat of Speldhurst and Bidborough.  And the councillor who had been the driving force behind the project, Cllr Tracy Moore (pictured below) also lost her seat in Park Ward, with Conservative candidates there receiving only 20% of the vote.

Cllr-Tracy-Moore Crop

Both Cllr Jukes and Cllr Moore lost decisively to the Tunbridge Wells Alliance Party, which was formed predominantly to fight the scheme that would construct a 1,200 seat theatre to replace the Assembly Hall.

The TW Alliance says the cost of the interest payments on the borrowing needed to fund the project will mean continuing cuts to council services for everyone in the Borough, which stretches from Southborough and Paddock Wood in the north to Hawkhurst and Cranbrook in the south.

The TW Alliance won 5 new seats on Thursday in addition to the one seat secured last year by Cllr Nick Pope (pictured below) who told Southborough News he thought the Civic Centre scheme to be built on part of Calverley Grounds near the BBC studios now only had a “30 per cent” chance of going ahead.

Nick Pope crop

The new Borough Council will have 28 Conservatives and 20 opposition councillors. However, several of the Conservatives are opposed to their party’s scheme or have abstained on past votes, so it is no longer clear there is a majority in the council to go ahead with the new buildings.

Nick Pope said: “We would have been relatively happy with 3 seats, but to win 5 out of our 6 seats that we put candidates up for is extremely good. The losses for the Conservatives in Tunbridge Wells are much worse than across the country and that’s because of local issues.”

Asked if the TW Alliance support had benefited from the disarray in national politics, Nick Pope told me: “A few people brought up Brexit, but that’s something that we kept away from because it is not a local issue. Our candidates are a mix of for and against Brexit, but that’s not a local issue”.

image e crop

Nick Pope told Southborough News that feeling in the town against the Calverley Grounds project is very strong. He says there has been a “massive change” in the electoral map after two rounds of annual voting for the Borough Council. Just over a year ago the Conservatives had 90% of the seats – now they have just 58% (28 out of 48 seats).

It would take just 5 Conservatives to support any vote to ditch the scheme for it to be sunk. The Conservative group on the Borough Council will have to choose another leader in the coming days and decide on a new policy.

After his defeat, former TWBC leader David Jukes told the Daily Telegraph: “To say I’m disappointed is an understatement. We have lost some good councillors, and with so many long-term projects in front of us, I’m worried this will have a devastating effect on economic growth.”

TW Alliance’s Cllr Pope said he would like to think the Conservatives will change direction. He said: “If they don’t, it would be very foolish and they will probably find they have strong opposition from within the council and from residents for the next year and until the next election.” The next vote for another third of councillors at Tunbridge Wells Borough Council will be in May 2020.

Civic Centre 1

Cllr Pope continued: “It is highly likely that Hoopers and others will appeal against the Compulsory Purchase Order decision which has just been approved by the Planning Inspectorate.  It is highly unlikely that they will start to build this year because the appeals will probably delay that.”

Cllr Pope concluded the probability of the £90 million development happening  has dropped well below 50%. He said: “Politically they would be very foolish to push ahead with it. It is probably dropping to about 30%. There’s a good chance it will be stopped”.

Cllr Pope concluded that voters had become increasingly angry at the Conservative’s plans, concluding: “There’s a feeling that the town is looking shabby and people will be paying more for garden waste. They’ve been suffering from reduced services over the past decade and they can only see that getting worse if there’s a large loan to pay off.”

David Elliott (pictured below), who was among those Conservatives who lost his Borough seat in Thursday’s vote, told Southborough News it was up to the remaining Conservatives to decide what path to follow next. But he felt the Civic scheme was well advanced and could still start building work in the next year.

Elliot crop v2

Cllr Elliott expressed his continued support for the scheme as a long term investment.   He said: “I can understand people being concerned about borrowing a lot of money for the future but it has been done before when the existing Town Hall and Assembly Hall were built. The loan for that has only just been paid off.”

Cllr Nick Pope argued it wasn’t too late to abandon the scheme.  He said: “The money they have spent is the equivalent of just over two years of loan repayments so it is a lot of money but it is a lot less than the project would cost and we can be pretty certain the project is not going to be £94 million but well over £ 100 million.”

Back in November 2017, Southborough News interviewed the Conservative Tracy Moore about why she believed the new theatre and Council offices were vital for the future of Tunbridge Wells. You can listen to a recording of what she said by clicking here:
http://bit.ly/2AlRPVZ

TWBC opposition now has 9 Liberal Democrats plus 6 for Tunbridge Wells Alliance, 4 for Labour and 1 Independent (who formerly was part of TW Alliance). Cllr Nick Blackwell (below) who leads the Labour group on Southborough Town Council called it a “seismic shock” for the Conservatives.

blackwell-v2

Cllr Blackwell said: “I can’t in my lifetime remember anything like this. For David Jukes to lose his seat in Speldhurst and Bidborough and for Tracey Moore to lose her seat in Park Ward, I don’t think anybody believed that would happen.”

Cllr Blackwell described the Conservative attitude locally as  “hubristic arrogance”. He said: “They will not listen to people and they plough on regardless and they don’t think they are accountable to the electorate”.

Cllr Blackwell concluded: “I would hope now people down at the Town Hall will realise that this (Civic development) is not viable. This is not going to happen. There isn’t the support in the Town. If they have got any sense this is the point where they take stock of where they are and rethink their position.”

In Tunbridge Wells Borough Council voting on Thursday:

Seats Won % of votes
Conservative 5 29%
Liberal Democrat 5 27%
TW Alliance 5 18%
Labour 2 12%
Independent 1 4%
UKIP 0 4%
Green Party 0 3%
Women’s Equality Party 0 2%

In nearby boroughs in Kent, the losses for the Conservatives were much less dramatic than in Tunbridge Wells. In Tonbridge and Malling, the Lib Dems won five seats, but the Tory council majority remains large. On TMBC, there are now 39 Conservatives against 15 from all opposition parties.

There was little change in Maidstone, where the Conservatives remain the largest party, but with no overall control, after losing one seat to Labour.

Here were some of the more dramatic results from wards around Tunbridge Wells on Thursday:

SPELDHURST & BIDBOROUGH Votes Share of Vote
Lucinda Willis TW Alliance 1007 51% Elected
David Jukes Cons 613 31% Not elected
Iola Palmer-Stirling Lib Dem 351 18% Not elected
PARK WARD for 2 seats Votes Share of Vote
Christian Atwood TW Alliance 1125 24% Elected
Rebecca Bruneau TW Alliance 1088 23% Elected
Tracy Moore Cons 539 11% Not elected
Rachel Sadler Lib Dem 486 10% Not elected
Gillian Douglass Lib Dem 482 10% Not elected
Victoria White Cons 437 9% Not elected
Linda Jagger Labour 211 4% Not elected
Victor Webb Independent 211 4% Not elected
Michael Jerrom UKIP 128 3% Not elected

In St John’s Ward there was a heavy defeat for the Conservative Tunbridge Wells Borough Councillor and Deputy Leader of Kent County Council, Peter Oakford.  Mr Oakford (pictured below) lives in Pennington Road in Southborough.

Peter-Oakford crop

ST JOHN’S WARD Votes Share of Vote
Marguerita Morton Lib Dem 1165 59% Elected
Peter Oakford Cons 347 18% Not elected
Benjamin Phillips Green 174 9% Not elected
Louise Reid Labour 154 8% Not elected
Robert Horan UKIP 125 6% Not elected

More results at:

http://democracy.tunbridgewells.gov.uk/meetings/mgElectionResults.aspx?ID=13&V=1&RPID=2278168

 

 

 

Conservatives Defeated Heavily on Town Council but “too late” to stop Hub

There has been a heavy defeat for the Conservatives on Southborough Town Council, putting Labour in charge of the new council with support from Liberal Democrats. But it seems to be too late to make any major changes to the Southborough Hub plans.

Labour’s Nick Blackwell (below) told Southborough News that he was overwhelmed by the turnout and wanted to say a big thank you to everyone who came out to vote.

Cllr Blackwell said: “We knew there was a lot of resentment about the way the Hub project had been conducted and the secrecy and arrogance of the previous Tory Council.  But it was really heartening to see that transfer into votes and seats on the Council.”

blackwell-v2

There is formally “no overall control” on the Town Council, with Labour becoming the largest party with 9 seats, the Conservatives will have 6 and the Liberal Democrats 3 seats.

Cllr Blackwell continued: “Going forward, what we are really keen to do is to open up and have a dialogue with people in the town and be transparent about the finances and I look forward to working with our colleagues in the Liberal Democrats to make sure that happens.”

Cllr Blackwell said people he spoke to on the doorstep were overwhelmingly voting on local issues, with many lifelong Conservatives unhappy with the planned Southborough Hub (shown below) and the Civic Project in Tunbridge Wells.

Nov18 Hub Air

Cllr Blackwell continued: “We did have a few people who were appalled at the way that Greg Clark has – in their words – betrayed them over Brexit and I think for a few Tory voters that was their reason to stay at home, although the vote as a whole was what we’d expect for a local election at this stage.”

The mayor of Southborough is now certain to be a Labour councillor, who will be elected at the first meeting of the new council on Tuesday 21st May.

The council will then choose a new “Hub lead” to replace the Conservative’s Ian Kinghorn.  However, the Conservatives will retain control of the 3 person Hub project as they still hold the other 2 places on the Southborough Hub project board, due to the Conservative majorities on the Tunbridge Wells Borough and Kent County Councils.

There seems no chance of any significant changes to the Hub scheme. Cllr David Elliott of the Conservatives, who stays on the Town Council, confirmed to Southborough News that all contracts were signed in March to progress with the building of the Hub.

Cllr Elliott said: “Although the Labour group may well be in control, they can’t stop it now. Even if Southborough Town Council votes against anything they are outnumbered by the other two (councils).”

Hub Nov18 Library

And Labour’s Cllr Blackwell said: “There is limited scope to change what has already been signed off.  All of the legal contracts have been signed with the various parties and the finances agreed, so a lot of the wheels are already in motion. The NHS funding has all been signed off.”

The cladding is not finally decided while Cllr Blackwell also thought there could be a revision to the current plan that the Tunbridge Wells Assembly Hall would run the Hub’s Hall with none of any profits going to Southborough Town Council.

The cladding planned for the Hub is apparently concrete that is digitally printed to look like terracotta stone, which still needs to be approved by Tunbridge Wells Planning.

Cllr David Elliott said: “We are handing over the Town Council in a very healthy financial state compared to what it was four years ago. We would liked to have retained control of the Town Council but it is not to be. We had all the important votes in March to enable the project to go ahead but I have to say I am rather disappointed.”

Cllr Elliott continued: “I fully understand why people wanted to retain the Royal Victoria Hall, but once the decision had been made and it had been demolished, why have the opposition parties continued to vote against everything we’ve tried to do?  Why can’t we all work together?”

Old Council New Council
North Ward – Cons 6 4
North Ward – Lib Dems 1 3
West Ward – Cons 1 0
West Ward – Labour 4 5
East+HB Ward – Cons 4 2
East +HB Ward – Labour 2 4
TOTAL STC – Cons 11 6
TOTAL STC – Labour 6 9
TOTAL STC – Lib Dems 1 3

In Southborough North ward, where 7 councillors are elected, only 10 people stood for election.  The 3 Liberal Democrats were significantly more popular than the 7 Conservatives, suggesting more Conservatives may have been defeated had the Lib Dems managed to find more than 3 candidates willing to stand.  The 4 Conservatives were effectively elected “by default.”

Here are the May 2019 Town Council election results in full.

TOWN COUNCIL – North Ward elects 7
POILE Trevor Lib Dem 922 Elected
PRANCE Jacqueline Lib Dem 694 Elected
BULLION Alan Lib Dem 631 Elected
ELLIOTT David Cons 477 Elected
KINGHORN Ian Cons 390 Elected
HARRIS Phil Cons 381 Elected
KINGHORN Olwyn Cons 367 Elected
JAMIL Nasir Cons 317 Not elected
WEATHERLY Lynne Cons 306 Not elected
UDDIN Mo Cons 265 Not elected

Below are pictured the three Lib Dems representing North Ward on the Town Council: Trevor Poile, Jackie Prance and Alan Bullion.

Lib Dem

TOWN COUNCIL – West Ward elects 5
BLACKWELL Nicholas Labour 408 Elected
EVANS Peter Labour 383 Elected
MUNN Graham Labour 380 Elected
WHARTON Mandy Labour 364 Elected
CLAY Martin Labour 345 Elected
BIRD Alexis Lib Dem 213 Not elected
MARKWELL Leah Cons 159 Not elected
OAKFORD Peter Cons 133 Not elected
MARKWELL Toby Cons 127 Not elected
BAILEY Matthew Cons 115 Not elected
ELDRIDGE Jon Cons 106 Not elected

 

TOWN COUNCIL – East & High Brooms elects 6
HILL Dianne Labour 681 Elected
LANE Yvonne Labour 603 Elected
FRANCIS Dariel Elizabeth Labour 584 Elected
LEWIS Alain Labour 563 Elected
LEWIS-GREY Alexander Cons 248 Elected
BACKHOUSE Bob Cons 245 Elected
CAMP Christopher Cons 231 Not elected
PULLER Max Cons 225 Not elected
SCOTT David Cons 224 Not elected
FARTHING Steven Cons 201 Not elected

 

Southborough’s Big Vote on Thursday

Southborough residents only get a chance to vote for their representatives on the Town Council once every four years and that big day is coming soon – Thursday 2nd May.

The Conservatives currently have a big majority on the Town Council and they have used their time in power to press ahead with plans to create the “Southborough Hub”, which is due to combine a new hall, library, medical centre and clubhouse for local footballers.

The Hub is likely to be a key issue in voters’ minds. The Conservatives had promised the Hub would be ready by now but repeated delays mean that – while the building of new housing to finance the project is well advanced – the planned new public facilities (see below for plans) have yet to start construction.

Nov18 Hub Air

In May 2017, bulldozers moved in to clear the site by demolishing the Local Heritage Asset, the Royal Victoria Hall, that had been part of Southborough’s history for a 117 years (see picture below from “Castles on the Ground” blog).

RVH demolish

All the issues surrounding the Hub and the Royal Victoria Hall have been extensively covered previously on this blog (see archive). There are 31 candidates for the 18 Town Council seats, which are all unpaid roles.

There are three different voting areas. The area covered by North Ward is shown below.

southboroughnorth

In the Southborough North Ward, 7 councillors will be elected from these 10 candidates, with voting taking place at St Thomas’s Church Hall in Pennington Road:

STC – North Ward Home Address Party
BULLION Alan Tun Wells TN2 Liberal Dem
ELLIOTT David Sir David’s Park Conservative
HARRIS Phil Park House Gdns Conservative
JAMIL Nasir Tun Wells Conservative
KINGHORN Ian West Park Ave Conservative
KINGHORN Olwyn West Park Ave Conservative
POILE Trevor Fernhurst Cres Liberal Dem
PRANCE Jacqueline Harland Way Liberal Dem
UDDIN Mo Tun Wells Boro Conservative
WEATHERLY Lynne Tun Wells Conservative

Meanwhile, in West Ward, it is considerably more competitive with 11 candidates chasing 5 seats, with voting at the Community Centre in Crundwell Rd:

STC – West Ward Home Address Party
BAILEY Matthew Tun Wells Conservative
BIRD Alexis Bright Ridge Liberal Dem
BLACKWELL Nicholas Pinewood Gdns Labour
CLAY Martin Gt Bounds Drive Labour
ELDRIDGE Jon Tun Wells Boro Conservative
EVANS Peter Holden Park Rd Labour
MARKWELL Leah Carville Ave Conservative
MARKWELL Toby Carville Ave Conservative
MUNN Graham Holden Park Rd Labour
OAKFORD Peter Pennington Rd Conservative
WHARTON Mandy Broomhill Pk Rd Labour

Finally, in Southborough East and High Brooms Ward, there are 10 candidates for 6 council seats with voting at St Matthew’s Church.

STC – East & High Brooms Home Address Party
BACKHOUSE Bob Tun Wells TN2 Conservative
CAMP Christopher Tun Wells TN2 Conservative
FARTHING Steven Tun Wells Boro Conservative
FRANCIS Dariel Elizabeth High Brooms Rd Labour
HILL Dianne Colebrook Rd Labour
LANE Yvonne South View Rd Labour
LEWIS Alain Holden Park Rd Labour
LEWIS-GREY Alexander Tun Wells Conservative
PULLER Max Tun Wells Boro Conservative
SCOTT David Tun Wells Conservative

The candidates’ address has been given by exact road if the candidate lives in Southborough. Some further details are on the Borough Council website.

Meanwhile, the Tunbridge Wells Borough elections are also taking place, with two council seats in play in Southborough.  Each area is represented by more than one councillor under a system of rolling votes for the Borough Council.

The main issue in the Borough election is the Conservative scheme to spend £ 90 million on building a new council run theatre and Tunbridge Wells Town Hall on part of Calverley Grounds (artist’s impression of plans below).  Previous bogs have also extensively covered this issue (see archive).

image e crop

Voting for the Borough is in two constituencies, with each electing one councillor.  In Southborough North, four parties are standing with the Conservatives having been victorious in 3 votes in the past four years, although the margin has varied.  This time the candidates are:

Southborough North Home Address
BLACKWELL Nicholas Pinewood Gdns Labour
ELLIOTT David St David’s Park Conservative
LUKACS Stephen Tun Wells TN2 UKIP
POILE Trevor Fernhurst Cres Liberal Dem

Four years ago, David Elliott won the seat convincingly for the Conservatives with 58% of the vote (1,343 votes), with Labour taking 16% (372), Liberal Democrats 15% (357) and UKIP 11% (256 votes).

But just four months later – in a by-election in September 2015, it was much closer in Southborough North, with just 50 votes in it, as the Conservatives took 44% (483 votes), Liberal Democrats 39% (434 votes) and UKIP 17% (188 votes).

Last year, Joe Simmons was returned for the Conservatives with 51% (614 votes), with Lib Dems on 29% (354 votes) and Labour on 20% (247 votes). There was no UKIP candidate.

The second Southborough area is a combination of the other two Town Council Wards and so is named Southborough and High Brooms. This seat has recently been won by both Labour and Conservative Parties.  Here are the candidates this time:

Southborough and High Brooms
BIRD Alexis Bright Ridge Liberal Dem
EVERITT Luke Tun Wells TN2 Labour
MARSHALL Christine Gordon Rd TN4 UKIP
PULLER Max Tun Wells Conservative

Four years ago, Zulhash Uddin won the seat for the Conservatives with 38% of the vote (1,289 votes), with Labour winning 36% (1,235), UKIP 16% (546) and Liberal Democrats 10% (325).  But last year, Labour won Southborough and High Brooms with 62% (1,094 votes), Conservatives 26% (455) and Lib Dems on 12% (211 votes).

Voting on Thursday will take place between 7am and 10pm.

Emmetts Garden Provides Springtime Inspiration for Gardeners

The National Trust’s Emmetts Garden is only 20 minutes drive from Southborough and its exotic shrubs are currently displaying magnificent springtime colours to energise local gardeners.

In contrast to this weekend’s sadly overcast weather, a fortnight ago (see below) the sun was shining brightly on Emmetts Garden, which is one of the highest spots in Kent.

P1150015.JPGP1150022.JPG

There is a huge collection of plants – large and small – in six acres of land.

P1150056.JPG

P1150055.JPGEmmetts Garden is an amazingly quiet, peaceful spot – well away from motorway noise and also usually free from the rumble of aeroplanes heading for Gatwick.  It is around 200 metres above sea level (600 feet), so offers glorious panoramic views over unblemished countryside.

P1140999.JPG

A banker, Frederic Lubbock, was responsible for the original planting out of the gardens in 1893-95, while the shrub garden was added ten years later.  Frederic’s elder brother was the ant expert and author Sir John Lubbock.

Emmetts Crop

After Frederic Lubbock’s death in 1927,  the estate was acquired by an American geologist Charles Watson Boise, who handed the estate (minus the house) to the National Trust in 1964.

P1150058Emmetts Garden is free for National Trust members but costs £12 for adult tickets and £30 for a family ticket. It opens every day from 10am to 5pm from March to December.  There is also a small cafe and a large picnic area and childrens’ play area.  You can walk through woodland to Chartwell.

On fine weekend days it does get busy and had to close briefly at around 2pm on the sunny Sunday a fortnight ago. It is quieter in the late afternoon. Here’s how to get there on the non-A21 picturesque route:

Emmetts Map.jpg

It takes 25 minutes by car on my country road route above, compared with 15 minutes if you follow the dreary “google map/satnav” A21 Sevenoaks By-pass route.  But the scenic route is cheaper on fuel! Just put “no motorways” in google maps to avoid the A21.

P1150019.JPG

P1150044.JPG

P1150054.JPGThe rock gardens and pond (above) are fenced in to prevent rabbits digging up the plants. The bluebells and rose garden will be attractions for the coming months, while the Trust also runs Easter egg hunts and – in August – holds open air theatre productions.

Wanted! Old News About Pennington Road

Southborough has a rich history to celebrate and on this blog over the coming year I hope to uncover first hand memories of how people lived in the town over the past 150 years.

In the past decade it has become much easier to trace the names and occupations of the people who lived in every street in Victorian England.

But what is so often missing is the colour – most of the letters and diaries of how people felt at the time – painting a picture of the personalities of Southborough people – all seem to have vanished into nothing.

I’m starting with Pennington Road, as that’s where I live and where I have already rediscovered some remarkable memories and pictures.  A postcard showing the Vicarage Road turn off on the left is below.

Penn Rd VicarRd

So my appeal is this:  If you have anything in a loft or out of print book that can conjure up life in Southborough from the 1840s to the 1930s, do let me know. My email is:

martin.webber10536@gmail.com

Pennington Road started as Pennington Lane, simply a route to apparently the oldest surviving building in Southborough, Ivy House Farm, described in the official English Heritage listing as a “single bay open hall dwelling of c.1460”.  See below:

Ivy House farm

Below is a map found in Southborough library described as “Plan of Freehold building and other land situate at Southborough in the parish of Tonbridge, Kent.” The plan states that an auction of the lots 1 to 18 shown below was held at the Hand and Sceptre Inn on July 2nd, 1849 at 3 o’clock.

Colour big.jpg

Closer up view….

Colour map 1850.jpg

The builders soon got to work and within ten years a good proportion of what survives in Pennington Road had been built.  This is from a map surveyed in 1869 – exactly 150 years ago!

Penn Rd map 1868 crop.jpg

A second map found in Southborough Library is drawn differently but is also from the 1860s and has the same selection of buildings.

Penn Rd 1860s cu.jpg

Finding out who lived in all these houses has been made easier by the online visibility of the ten yearly census and the Kelly’s street directories.  But it is still not that simple.

In the census of 1861, Pennington Road has no numbering system. The set of terraces next to Castle Street (shown below now and in approx 1911) appeared to have been described as “Edward Place”.

Edward crop

Pen 1

By the census of 1881, houses were numbered but the Post Office had decided to count sequentially starting down the right hand side of the road.  Edward Sheepwash  was a resident of the house on the far right in 1911.  The census calls him a “job master” and his sign is just visible above and reads “Fly and Funeral Car Proprietor. Carriages of Every Description.”

Back in 1881, Mr Sheepwash’s house was number 7 and living there then was a greengrocer called William J. Carpenter. By the time Mr Sheepwash had his sign up, the Post Office had had a rethink and renumbered to the current scheme, so all the houses on the south of Pennington Road had a number double their original ones. Mr Sheepwash therefore lived in 14 Pennington Road.

A great website with the residents from the 1881 census clearly laid out according to the old numbering system (ie half the current number) is here:

http://bit.ly/2Tyafzp

Here are some more views of St Thomas’ Church completed in 1860.

Penn Church 2.jpg

St Thomas’ Church was consecrated by the Archbishop of Canterbury on 4th December 1860, in the presence of the 85 year-old Mrs Sarah Pugh, at whose expense the church had been built and endowed. In 1871 the church was given its own parish, carved out of what had been St Peter’s parish.  For more see:

https://www.stthomassouthborough.org.uk/our-history

Penn Church 1

Most of the following pictures come courtesy of Mr Fred Scales of Edward Street who has a magnificent collection of images of Southborough past. So let’s walk further down the road…

pen 4

In the middle of the picture above is the building now known as “The Old Dairy” – another of Pennington Road’s listed buildings.  It used to be two separate cottages and there’s another closer view on the left in the pictures below.  In 1861, they were “Deacons Cottages”. Eliza Collins was a resident in 1861 and – remarkably – for all the following 40 years too, by which time her house had been known as 44 Pennington Road and (by 1891) number 5 Pennington Road. Penn Rd crop v2.jpg

Pen 8.jpg

Off on the right are what I think were once called “Stanley Villas”.  One of them is now number 34 Pennington Road and shown below – many years before the grey render walls were painted white.

No 34 full crop.jpg

It would be fascinating to know who the people in the picture above were.  Without doubt they would have known some of the Gallards – a family that played a huge part in the history of Pennington Road.

Penn Stile .jpgCharles Gallard (1823-1885) was the builder who probably put up many of the Pennington Road houses in the 1850s.  He had a son – also a builder – Charles J. Gallard (1850-1906), who’s bequest funded the Gallards Almshouses, and who left his mark with the many drain covers still in use in Pennington Road today.

P1140897.JPG

Charles Gallard’s first wife died in 1852, but he remarried a few years later.  As a result, Charles J. Gallard had one sister, plus 3 half brothers and 7 half sisters. Among his half sisters was a lady called Isabella Gallard (1861-1952).  I’m pleased to say that – remarkably – I have spoken recently to a lady who gave me a first hand of what Isabella was like.

The lady was Isabella’s niece who moved into 36 Pennington Road in the 1950s when her family came to look after Isabella, then 90 years old. The picture of Isabella Gallard on a horse was apparently from 1909 in Ireland.

Issie only crop

Isabella Gallard was clearly a stubborn lady – she was still insisting in the 1950s that electricity was “far too dangerous” to have in the house and all the lighting in number 36 was still by gas. Her house had a “tradesman’s entrance” although the path started and ended from the same places and just involved the tradesmen walking to the left of the hedge while the ladies and gentlemen walked up a different path to the right of the hedge.

How I tracked down a relative of Isabella Gallard is a story for another blog, but I learnt some fascinating detail and I am hoping – that with this blog – I can capture a lot more.

Further down Pennington Road (but still before Park Road) is the house once called Mount Sandford – now 44. Pictured then and now.

Mt Sandford big.jpg

P1140917

In the picture taken this week you can see number 44A has been added (far left), while to the right in this picture is a building on the site of the demolished old 42 (formerly 21 and formerly Shenley Villas). Then there is the still surviving Victorian building number 40 (now divided into two large semi-detatched houses 40 and 40A with some huge trees in their front gardens).  Finally, number 38 was demolished in the 1980s and is now Dennington Court flats, whose red roof tiles are just visible on the far right above.

Newspaper articles can play a part in adding colour to the historical facts.  An article from November 6, 1874 in the Courier discusses legal action taken by the local board against the first Charles Gallard “for refusing to pay £9 14s 8d” relating to work paving Pennington Road.

Pen 5.jpgThe article says: “In April 1873 it was determined that the road should be properly paved and flagged and notice was thereupon given to the owners of the land abutting on the road, requiring them to do the repairs in accordance with certain specifications which were deposited at the surveyor’s offices.”

It appears most owners didn’t do the work, so the Local Board did the work itself and then charged the land owners.  Mr Gallard apparently didn’t agree that the Local Board had the power to do this, as he argued “Pennington-road was a highway dedicated to the parish.”

A Mr Stidolph, who was a surveyor of the Southborough roads in 1856-57 spoke in support of Mr Gallard, stating that the road then was “in a very bad state, and Mr Corke, who got stuck fast in the road, talked about indicting the surveyor.”  The surveyor ordered road improvements.

View from Mt Sandford No 44.jpgBut the Local Board solicitor insisted that “the surveyor, putting a few stones upon the road at parish expense did not make it a public road….there must be evidence of dedication.”

The report ends with the bench concluding that this road “up to a gate at the end of Mr Blackburn-Maze’s property” (then number 37 – i.e. the last before the farm) “was a public highway, therefore the Local Board have no status”.

This result appears to be victory for Mr Gallard in avoiding the Local Board’s bills, even though everyone else in Pennington Road appeared to have already paid up to the Council.  The Gallards do indeed seem to have been a stubborn lot.

Finally for this blog is a (unfortunately somewhat blurred) picture of the terraces that were 26-30, now 52 to 60 Pennington Road.

Pen 3.jpg

The pictures conjour up a quieter time without the traffic and aeroplane noise. In Victorian times, the census shows Pennington Road was a mix of terraces for the working classes (carpenters, gardeners etc) and reasonably large villas for the middle class such as retired military gentlemen, widows “living on independent means” and doctors.  The villas all had servants to clean, cook and light the open coal fireplaces.

The newspaper archives also reveal how people of Pennington Road came together in August 1887 as 110 local residents signed a petition which was presented to the Local Board (council).  This petition was in opposition to potential extra traffic on the road thanks to an apparent scheme for a Southborough railway station at the viaduct, accessed via Pennington Road.

The petition read: “The traffic of a station thoroughfare would be extremely detrimental to their comfort and interests, whether as occupiers or owners; that it would entirely ruin the present rural privacy and quiet of the properties on both sides of Pennington-road….it would much deteriorate the value of the villas already built by altering the character of the road and so making them less desirable for their present class of tenants.”

View from Ampthill 46 & 48 Penn. Rd.jpgThe petition argues that the result of a Southborough station would: “be the encouragement of cheap trippers, in any multitude, to visit the Southborough Common; whereas at present most of these disperse themselves among the nearer and larger commons adjacent to the Tunbridge Wells station, and leave Southborough alone.”

The Local Board correctly concluded that the railway had no plan at all to put a station at the viaduct and were aiming instead to put one “in Tunbridge Wells by the Grosvenor Bridge”.  A certain Mr Powell told the meeting: “The Southborough station was a sort of red herring thrown across the tract.”