Debate Heats Up on Council’s Big Debt to Refit RVP Palm Court Area

There’s been a lively reaction on social media to the news that Tunbridge Wells Borough Council has overwhelmingly approved huge borrowing to fund development of the town’s RVP shopping centre.

Southborough News has now published a 4 minute video of the event, while an excellent commentary on last week’s council meeting has also been published by independent journalist Simon Barnes.

The decision to add a new roof and better toilets seemed like essential maintenance.

But more than half the £23million to be spent was related to a big rebuild designed to create a new basement leisure area to replace the food court. The food court was deliberately run down and emptied by previous owners before the council took over.

Only one resident, James Tansley, spoke at the meeting, calling the plans “totally delusional”.

Meanwhile, Alex Greig of Fuggles Beer Cafe said the council spending would help businesses like his “thrive not just survive.”

Southborough News’ first post on Nextdoor site was seen by 2,000 local residents, while the Facebook interview video has been seen by hundreds more.

Several were in support of the plans but most comments were critical, including this from Ruslan in Hawkenbury:
“26 councillors have committed the borough to around £23m of borrowing, with about £1.5m a year in repayments, potentially for 50 years. By my own sums from the council’s figures, that could mean about £74m repaid in total.

That’s a decision that will outlast most of us, and it was taken without a single public question allowed at the meeting. The “73% support” quoted in the papers comes from 215 survey answers, in a borough of over 115,000 people.

Many residents I’ve received a comments from had never heard of the consultation, while over 6,000 people signed the petition to save the snooker centre. Councillors are elected to make decisions, but on something this big and this long-lasting, residents should have been properly asked and properly heard.

I hope the full engagement report, and the detail of how views were counted, will now be published.”

Here is the Simon Barnes free substack article:

Here is the Southborough News video (filmed by myself, Martin Webber), with a transcript below…
YOUTUBE 3 min version:
https://youtube.com/shorts/7yiVbeQAapY

Link to Facebook 4 min version:
https://fb.watch/KVLXY9EQjp/

Link to Instagram 4 min version:
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DfxakSDCTlO/?utm_source=ig_web_button_share_sheet&psln=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==

ALEX GREIG, Owner of Fuggles Beer Café:
“I personally have invested heavily this year in my own expansion and refurbishment of Fuggles.

Part of that decision was based on the confidence that I have – and the hope that I have – that the plans, both phase one, two, and three, for Royal Victoria Place, do go through and do happen.

It gives me great confidence for the future of my own business and for the success of the town as well. I think it will help businesses to thrive, not just survive.”

JAMES TANSLEY, Resident:
“Now the council wants to refurbish the Palm Court. It argues that the project will be self-financing.

Yet anyone with an understanding of finance will conclude that the assumptions behind the business plan go beyond the merely fanciful into the realms of the totally delusional.

When challenged about the figures, an official from the council’s finance department claimed that the auditors were “comfortable”. Yet, a subsequent Freedom of Information request revealed that, far from “comfortable” with the business plan, the auditors had not even been consulted.

It is clear that refurbishment will not be self-financing. No decision should be taken until after next May’s elections, to give the people of this borough a choice. Stop this madness, reject this motion.”

JUSTINE RUTLAND, Lib Dem Deputy Council Leader:
“It is the latest staging post on our shopping centre journey. It is a refurbishment and repurposing that brings Palm Court into the 2020s, the 2030s, and beyond, evolving to meet changing consumer and business demands.

Now, before I continue, I must respond to a speaker’s suggestion that the council may have misled councillors and the public.

I refute them most strongly, and I’m disappointed that they have come up again despite the council previously commenting and clarifying.

The comment made during the FITCAB committee discussion was clearly generalist. The recording confirms that our officer was speaking regarding the general treatment elsewhere in relation to information gleaned from the internet, and that the auditors had been comfortable with that approach.

There was no reference to the council’s own auditors, and the comments at this point were not about this council. The council does not accept the suggestion that members or the public were misled.

This matter has not been raised with the auditors. There is no need to raise it with the auditors. This council is free to make such decisions.”

DIANNE HILL, Labour voted against:
“I’ve spoken to many residents that I represent. Very few think this is a very good idea. I am not saying, “do nothing”, but does it have to be on such a huge scale and with such debt?

I’m not meaning to turn this into a debate on the cost of living global crisis, but it doesn’t sit right with me. It’s not why I became a counsellor to spend taxpayers money when they don’t really know – and it seems like a lot of them don’t know – what this is about.

So, I can’t support it. I was not elected to put future generations in yet more needless debt.”

HUGO POUND, Labour voted in favour:
“It isn’t just a willy nilly, sort of decision made by some inexperienced or lacking in knowledge members. We have been led through this process very rigorously and properly by experts and I think that needs to be acknowledged.

We need to do something that helps this community in Tunbridge Wells to flourish. And I believe that this development contributes to that.”

BEN CHAPELARD, Lib Dem Leader of Council
“We are a force for good. We are behaving in the town’s and the Borough’s best interest. Of course, there’s a risk. Nobody can predict what’s going to happen in 50 years’ time, but with all the information that I’ve got available today, I believe this is the best thing we can do for our town, and I’d encourage colleagues to support the motion tonight.”

Leave a Reply